We’ve all had those nights when yesterday’s dinner is sitting in the fridge and the last thing we want to do is cook again. Reheating leftovers is convenient, but food safety depends more on how the food was handled and stored than on whether you use a microwave, oven, or skillet.
Some foods have a higher risk of bacterial growth if they’re left at room temperature for too long or cooled and stored incorrectly. Reheating may kill some bacteria, but it doesn’t always destroy toxins that bacteria have already produced.
That doesn’t mean you have to throw away every leftover in your refrigerator. It means knowing which foods need extra care and following basic storage and reheating practices. Here are 10 foods that deserve a little more attention.
Seafood
Seafood can spoil quickly if it isn’t chilled soon after cooking. Shrimp, fish, and other seafood should be refrigerated within two hours of cooking, or within one hour if the surrounding temperature is above 90°F.
The problem isn’t simply reheating. Seafood that has been stored improperly may already contain harmful bacteria or toxins, and reheating may not make it safe to eat.
If your seafood was refrigerated promptly and handled properly, reheating it thoroughly is generally fine. If you aren’t sure how long it sat out, it’s safer to throw it away rather than risk getting sick.
Related: 15 Foods Surprisingly Linked to Microplastic Exposure
Spinach
Spinach contains naturally occurring nitrates, which is why some advice warns against reheating cooked spinach. The concern is that under certain conditions, nitrates can be converted into nitrites and other compounds.
That said, reheating spinach isn’t automatically dangerous. The bigger concern is proper storage and keeping cooked food chilled rather than leaving it at room temperature.
If you have leftover cooked spinach, refrigerate it soon after the meal and keep it cold until you’re ready to eat it. You can also enjoy it chilled in a salad, wrap, or pasta dish.
Potatoes
Potatoes can become a food safety concern if cooked potatoes are left sitting at room temperature for extended periods. In particular, potatoes wrapped in foil and left warm for too long can create conditions that allow Clostridium botulinum to grow.
Reheating doesn’t necessarily destroy the toxins produced by this bacteria.
After cooking potatoes, refrigerate leftovers within two hours and keep them properly chilled. If you have mashed or baked potatoes left over, you can also turn them into potato cakes, hash, or another dish rather than simply reheating them the same way.
Related: These 17 Foods Have Become Surprisingly Expensive
Rice
Cooked rice is one of the foods that requires careful storage. Raw rice can contain Bacillus cereus spores, which may survive cooking. If cooked rice sits at room temperature for too long, the bacteria can multiply and produce toxins.
Those toxins may remain even after the rice is reheated.
The safest habit is to refrigerate leftover rice as soon as possible after cooking and keep it chilled. If rice has been sitting on the counter for several hours, don’t rely on reheating to make it safe.
Pizza
Cold pizza has plenty of fans, but reheated pizza can also be perfectly safe when it has been stored properly. The toppings aren’t inherently dangerous simply because the pizza is reheated.
The bigger concern is how long the pizza spent at room temperature before it went into the refrigerator. Meat, cheese, and other toppings can support bacterial growth if food is left out too long.
For a crisp crust, reheat pizza in an oven, toaster oven, or skillet instead of relying on the microwave. If it has been refrigerated promptly, eating it cold is also an option.
Mushrooms
Mushrooms have a reputation for being unsafe to reheat, but reheating itself isn’t the main issue. Cooked mushrooms can be stored and reheated safely if they’ve been handled correctly.
The concern comes from leaving cooked mushrooms at room temperature for too long, which gives bacteria a chance to multiply.
Keep leftover mushroom dishes refrigerated and eat them within a reasonable amount of time. They can also be added cold to salads or used in sandwiches if you prefer not to heat them again.
Related: 13 Surprisingly Common Foods People Are Embarrassed to Like
Pasta
Plain cooked pasta can be reheated without much trouble if it has been stored correctly. The bigger concern often comes from what has been added to it.
Cream sauces, meat sauces, cheese, and other ingredients can spoil if the finished dish is left out for too long. Bacillus cereus can also grow on cooked pasta under poor storage conditions.
Refrigerate leftover pasta within two hours and reheat it until it’s hot throughout. If you have a cold pasta salad in mind, make sure the ingredients have also been kept properly chilled.
Eggs
Cooked eggs can be stored and reheated safely when they’re handled correctly. The idea that reheating eggs automatically makes them dangerous isn’t accurate.
The real concern is bacterial growth caused by improper storage. Eggs and dishes containing eggs should be refrigerated promptly after cooking and kept cold.
If you’re reheating scrambled eggs, an omelet, or another egg dish, heat it thoroughly without leaving it sitting at room temperature afterward. Leftover eggs can also be added to a sandwich or salad if you prefer them cold.
Cooking Oils
Reusing or repeatedly heating cooking oil is different from reheating a leftover meal. Oil can break down after repeated exposure to high temperatures, especially if it’s used over and over for frying.
This can affect both the flavor and quality of the oil. Fried foods also tend to absorb oil during cooking, which is why reheating the same food repeatedly can leave it greasy and unpleasant.
For leftover fried foods, use an oven, air fryer, or skillet to warm them instead of adding more oil. If you’re deep-frying at home, avoid repeatedly reusing oil that’s dark, smoky, foamy, or has an unpleasant smell.
Related: 20 Foods That May Help Keep Your Arteries Healthy
Chicken
Chicken is one of the foods that deserves careful handling after cooking. Raw and cooked poultry can carry bacteria such as Salmonella, and leaving cooked chicken at room temperature gives bacteria time to multiply.
Reheating chicken won’t make improperly stored meat safe. If chicken has been left out too long, it’s better to discard it.
For properly stored leftovers, refrigerate chicken within two hours and reheat it until it reaches 165°F internally. Keep portions small when reheating so the center gets hot without drying out the outside.
The Real Issue Is Often Storage
Many foods on this list aren’t inherently unsafe to reheat. The bigger problem is what happened to them before they reached the microwave or oven.
Cooked leftovers should generally be refrigerated within two hours and kept at 40°F or below. If food has been sitting out for several hours, smells unusual, or you’re unsure how long it has been unrefrigerated, don’t take chances.
Good food safety habits matter more than whether you reheat a particular food once or twice. Store leftovers quickly, keep your refrigerator cold, reheat food thoroughly, and throw away anything that may have been sitting out too long.
