12 Failed Restaurant Chains That Couldn’t Stand the Test of Time
This post may contain affiliate links.
Over 749,404 restaurants operate across the country, with chains accounting for a significant portion of this number. Fast food giants like McDonald’s and Starbucks dominate the scene, with thousands of locations and billions in revenue each year. McDonald’s alone serves over 69 million customers daily globally.
Most chains fail due to insufficient financial oversight, ineffective leadership, failure to adapt to changing consumer preferences, and market saturation. Platforms like Yelp and social media shape public opinion in real time; a couple of negative reviews can turn potential customers away for good. These 12 failed restaurant chains once showed great potential but couldn’t stand the test of time.
Chi-Chi’s
Chi-Chi’s was once a beloved Mexican restaurant chain known for its festive atmosphere and signature dishes like chimichangas. Launched in 1975, Chi-Chi’s expanded rapidly, boasting over 200 locations at its peak.
The chain made headlines in 2003 when a hepatitis A outbreak linked to their food led to over 650 reported cases. By 2003, the company had filed for bankruptcy, and after rebranding efforts, it ultimately closed its doors for good in 2008.
Bennigan’s
Bennigan’s was a popular Irish-themed casual dining chain. Founded in 1976, it flourished throughout the late ’80s and ’90s, boasting over 350 locations at its peak.
Despite its attempts to charm diners with dishes like “Death by Chocolate” and “Monte Cristo Sandwiches,” the chain struggled to keep pace with changing consumer preferences. By 2008, the chain filed for bankruptcy, closing down over 150 locations across the U.S.
Steak and Ale
Founded in 1966, this chain succeeded by combining affordable steaks with a casual dining experience. However, according to The New York Times, the chain’s decline was exacerbated by a staggering 58 closures in just a few short years.
Steak and Ale stagnated with a menu that couldn’t compete as consumer trends moved toward fresher, more innovative dining options. The final nail in the coffin came when parent company Metromedia initiated a series of bankruptcy filings in the early 2000s.
Howard Johnson’s
This chain was famous for its bright orange roofs and iconic 28 signature dishes, including their beloved fried clams and delectable 28-flavor ice cream. At its peak in the 1960s, the chain boasted over 1,000 locations across the United States, but by 2005, there were fewer than eight.
According to Business Insider, the chain’s struggles began as it failed to evolve alongside changing consumer tastes and expectations. The inability to modernize and compete with faster, cheaper alternatives like Burger King led to its downfall. The last remaining location closed in 2022.
Sambo’s
Founded in 1957 in Santa Barbara, California, Sambo’s served breakfast classics alongside whimsical decor featuring a tiger and a little boy (that’s where the name comes from). The name, cheekily referencing a children’s storybook, “The Story of Little Black Sambo,” faced backlash for its racial insensitivity, especially during the Civil Rights Movement.
By the late 1970s, some locations began to rebrand, but alas, it was too late to escape the damage; by 1982, the chain dwindled to just 47 locations, and by 2005, virtually none remained.
Sbarro
Founded in 1956, Sbarro quickly gained popularity by serving up oversized slices of pizza and classic Italian dishes in a fast-casual setting. By 2020, the chain had closed over 200 locations, leaving only around 600 in operation.
According to a 2014 Food Quality Assurance Magazine report, the company’s focus on high-volume, low-quality meals alienated its customer base. The chain filed for bankruptcy twice—in 2011 and again in 2014—indicating deep-rooted operational challenges.
Planet Hollywood
Founded in 1991, this themed eatery was a pop-culture phenomenon at first. It boasted locations in cities like New York and Las Vegas and was adorned with memorabilia from the biggest blockbusters. However, as the initial novelty wore off, so did the patronage.
By the early 2000s, the chain struggled, with over $40 million in debts and a decline in customer interest. The combination of uninspired food and extravagant prices led to numerous closures, with the iconic flagship location in Las Vegas shutting down in May 2023.
Damon’s Grill
This once-popular chain thrived in the 1990s, boasting a unique mix of casual dining and sports bar vibes. At its peak, Damon’s had over 30 locations, enticing families with their notoriously oversized portions and an extensive menu that attempted to do too much.
Their over-saturated menus resulted in inconsistent food quality across locations. Between 1992 and 2007, Damon’s struggled against rising competitors like Applebee’s and Chili’s, who offered better marketing strategies and demonstrated a knack for keeping their menus fresh and exciting. By 2007, after years of financial turbulence and closures, Damon’s Grill shut its doors for good.
Fashion Café
Launched in 1995, the Café aimed to blend the worlds of high fashion and fine dining, bringing a slice of supermodel chic to the plates of eager patrons. Famous names like Naomi Campbell and Elle Macpherson lent their glamour to the brand.
In his 2011 book Brand Failures, Matt Haig states, “The link between models and food was not immediately apparent, and the theme of “fashion” did not evoke a sense of hunger.” The Buti brothers faced $15 million in lawsuits regarding unpaid taxes, rent, utility fees, and unemployment insurance premiums, leading to their closure in 1998.
Bob’s Big Boy
Established in 1936, it thrived for decades, primarily known for its iconic double-decker cheeseburger and the cheerful chubby mascot that welcomed diners with open arms. However, stifled innovation, inconsistent quality, and an outdated image led the chain to lose its once-vibrant customer base.
By 2018, only about 50 locations were left, a sharp decline from its peak of over 1,200 in the 1960s. This drop can be attributed to increasing competition from modern burger joints and fast-casual dining options that captured consumers’ hearts (and wallets).
Rainforest Cafe
Once a favorite for family outings, this themed restaurant promised an adventure through the sights and sounds of the rainforest, complete with animatronic animals and a tropical ambiance.
Despite its unique jungle-themed experience, Rainforest Cafe struggled with high maintenance costs and an inability to attract repeat customers. The novelty wore off, and locations began to shutter, unable to sustain long-term profitability.
Kenny Rogers Roasters
Launched in 1991, this chicken chain, co-founded by country music star Kenny Rogers himself, initially had a warm reception. It offered a unique offering of wood-smoked chicken and homestyle sides. Who wouldn’t be excited about that chicken?
At its peak, Kenny Rogers Roasters boasted over 350 locations, but with rapid growth, quality control suffered. Boston Chicken (now Boston Market) also fiercely competed. In 1998, the company declared bankruptcy and was sold to Nathan’s Famous for $1.25 million.
Disclaimer – This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information.
Riches Without Work: 8 Powerful Assets To Achieve Wealth And Quit Your Job
8 Powerful Assets to Achieve Wealth and Quit Your Job
15 Things to Never Buy at The Home Depot
Statista reports that in 2022, The Home Depot recorded over 1.6 billion customer transactions globally. Sweet Home Depot is the land of endless lumber, shiny new tools, and some rather dubious deals.
15 Things to Never Buy at The Home Depot
22 Red Flags That Scream ‘Run’ When Dining At A Restaurant
A bad dining experience can be the worst. Poor service, dirty tables, cold food, and unhygienic practices are red flags to watch out for when dining out. To ensure a good restaurant visit, we’ve compiled twenty warning signs to make you run for the door.
