Buying a house means taking ownership of the property, including the trees, gardens, and other things the previous owners left behind. But when a tree holds years of family memories, deciding who gets to enjoy its fruit can turn a simple favor into an uncomfortable situation.
That happened to one homeowner who bought a house with a mature plum tree in the backyard. The former owner had used its fruit to make homemade jam for nearly 20 years, so the new homeowner agreed to let her return when the plums were ripe.
The request seemed harmless at first. After one visit, though, the new homeowner had second thoughts about letting her come back.
She Didn’t Come for Just a Few Plums
When the former owner arrived, she brought her husband, two buckets, and a ladder. According to the homeowner’s Reddit post, the couple picked nearly every ripe plum they could reach, including fruit from branches hanging over the patio.
They also reportedly left broken twigs and fallen fruit scattered around the yard. What had sounded like a request for a small amount of fruit turned into a much larger harvest, leaving the new homeowner with little to enjoy from their own tree.
Related: 14 Easygoing Dog Breeds Every First-Time Owner Should Consider
She Expected to Return the Following Year
When the next plum season arrived, the former owner contacted the homeowner to ask which weekend would work for another visit. This time, the homeowner said no, explaining that they wanted to keep the fruit for themselves.
The former owner was unhappy and brought up the tree’s sentimental value to her family. She offered a few jars of homemade jam, while the homeowner’s sister suggested letting her take one bucket each year as a compromise.
The homeowner still felt that the arrangement had gone too far. Once the house was sold, the tree belonged to its new owners, and the former owner’s memories didn’t give her an ongoing claim to its harvest.
Related: 10 Things You Should Never Do When Selling Your House
Reddit Users Sided With the New Homeowner
Many commenters agreed that the homeowner was within their rights to refuse another visit. Their main complaint wasn’t that the former owner wanted plums, but that she appeared to take far more than the homeowner had agreed to share.
Bringing a ladder also raised safety and responsibility concerns. If someone fell or damaged the property while picking fruit, the new homeowner could be left dealing with an unpleasant situation.
Some commenters suggested that the former owner could take a cutting from the tree and try growing a new one. That would let her preserve a connection to the family’s old home without returning every summer to pick fruit.
Related: 12 Popular Garden Plants That Every Cat Owner Should Watch Out For
Could Sharing the Plums Have Worked?
The arrangement might have turned into a pleasant yearly tradition if the former owner had taken a modest amount and left the yard in good condition. A bucket of plums could have been a reasonable way for the new owners to honor the family’s memories while still enjoying the tree themselves.
Instead, the first visit left the homeowner reluctant to repeat the experience. The situation raises a question many new homeowners might face: would you let a former owner return for one bucket of plums each year, or would you draw the line after a visit like this one?
Related: 13 Household Repairs Most Homeowners Can Handle Themselves
