12 Times the KonMari Method Just Doesn’t Work

This post may contain affiliate links.

Marie Kondo’s philosophy of tidying up has been life changing for many. Her method of decluttering by keeping only what ‘sparks joy’ falls in line with a universe that is more and more attracted to minimalism. It’s charmingly simple: to hold an item, feel its energy and decide whether it is worthy of a place in your life. The result? Spaces that are calm, organized, and make you feel like you have it all together.

But let’s face it, life isn’t always tidy. The KonMari Method is amazing for most people, but sometimes it just doesn’t work. Some stuff of modern life just can’t be made neat and tidy with Marie Kondo’s method. Check out some of these relatable moments where the sparks don’t exactly fly.

Items With Sentimental Weight

Imagine telling someone to toss Grandma’s quilt because it doesn’t match their decor. Items that are sentimental have memory and meaning that are beyond joy. At other times, it’s not about what sparks joy, but what sparks a connection to a loved one or a special moment.

Shared Spaces and Opinions

I’m sure if you’ve ever done decluttering with a roommate or partner you will know that this can spark some interesting conversations. That “useless” gadget you feel they won’t let go of? It’s their treasure. The KonMari Method doesn’t factor in these compromises, and decluttering becomes a negotiation.

Parents and the Toy Explosion

Decluttering toys with kids is a Herculean task, Marie Kondo must not have stepped on a LEGO at 2 a.m. Almost everything will bring a smile to a child’s face, even if it’s that Happy Meal toy from three years ago. The KonMari Method leaves no roadmap for dealing with the chaos of childhood clutter.

Books: A Whole Other Chapter

15 Household Items Even the Craftiest Burglar Won't Steal from Your House — Photo Credit: Dom J/Pexels

Don’t you remember when Kondo said we might only need 30 books so as to prevent clutter? That’s laughable for book lovers. How do you take a library of stories, knowledge, and escapism and reduce it to just a few shelves? Books are where the KonMari Method often runs into a wall: stories can be inspiring before you even read them.

The “What-If” Items

What about those things you don’t use each day but might need someday? That extra set of dishes or camping gear or that toolkit doesn’t bring you daily joy, but when the moment comes, you are glad you did not throw it away. This might be another argument that the KonMari method may leave no room for practical foresight.

Craft Supplies

I think if you ask any artist or crafter to pare down their stash, you will see panic set in. Perhaps, those scraps of fabric or jars of buttons won’t bring you joy right now, but they are future potential. The KonMari Method doesn’t really deal with creativity’s messy side.

The Overflow Drawer

Things You Should Ditch After 30: Are These Still in Your Home? — Photo Credit: Hportfacts5/Wikimedia Commons

Oh, you know the infamous junk drawer? It’s not a flaw, it’s a necessity. It probably doesn’t spark joy, but it sparks convenience. Otherwise, you’d be looking for batteries, take out menus, and other random screws. Some chaos is just practical.

Inherited Clutter

"12 Antiques Set to Skyrocket in Value, According to Top Designers" — Image Credit: Pexels/ Pixabay

Emotionally, it’s hard to declutter inherited items. Of course, not all items give personal joy, but they instead feel tethered to family history as obligation. Tossing Aunt Ethel’s antique teacups is not exactly on anyone’s wish list.

Minimalism vs. Real Life

Sometimes, aesthetics is sacrificed on the altar of practicality. It might be trendy to have a minimalist wardrobe, but those extra hoodies you wear on lazy days shouldn’t go anywhere. Not every bit of life is to be Instagram-worthy.

Gifts You Feel Guilty Tossing

Asian Household Practices That Americans Find Astonishing — Image Credits: Pashtett/123rf

You can have gifts with strings—guilt being one of them. Tossing that sweater your aunt gave you because it does not spark joy could make you feel bad at a later time. This method of decluttering doesn’t quite solve the guilt dilemma.

Hobbies That Collect Dust

This is something anyone who’s ever had a fleeting hobby knows. Maybe that yoga mat, or guitar, doesn’t bring you joy now, but it’s part of you, and who knows? You may want to rekindle it someday. It’s too final to say goodbye.

It Doesn’t Fit Every Culture

Facts About Native Americans Most People Don't Know — Image Credit: Sharon’soutlook/Flickr

The KonMari Method is founded in cultural underpinnings of Japanese values. That’s beautiful, but it doesn’t always translate globally. Each culture has its own (and sometimes huge) ideas about just how important possessions are.

Disclaimer: This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information.