12 Underrated Shows That Have Won Awards
This post may contain affiliate links.
In the vast ocean of television shows, some gems remain largely unexplored by the mainstream audience. These underrated shows have captivated their niche audiences and garnered critical acclaim, bagging numerous awards. These underrated shows might not boast high ratings or widespread popularity. Still, their exceptional storytelling, compelling characters, and innovative approaches have earned them accolades from industry experts and devoted fans alike.
This exploration delves into these underrated yet award-winning shows, celebrating their achievements and highlighting why they deserve a place on your watchlist. Gripping dramas and innovative comedies have offered a rich viewing experience that is a testament to their artistic excellence and the talent behind their creation.
Rectify
Award: Peabody Award (2014)
Rectify tells the poignant story of Daniel Holden, who is released from death row after 19 years when new DNA evidence overturns his conviction. The show is not just about the protagonist’s post-prison life; it explores human behavior, community dynamics, and the quest for redemption. Its slow-burning narrative allows viewers to fully comprehend the psychological trauma inflicted on Daniel and those around him.
The show won the Peabody Award in 2014 for its groundbreaking storytelling and emotional depth. Critics have often praised its atmospheric tone and nuanced performances, with Time Magazinedescribing it as “a mesmerizing meditation on doubt, forgiveness, and the human condition.”
Halt and Catch Fire
Award: Critics’ Choice Television Award for Best Supporting Actor (2016)
Set against the backdrop of the 1980s tech boom, Halt and Catch Fire follows a group of brilliant but flawed individuals trying to innovate in the rapidly evolving world of technology. The show’s strength lies in its character development and ability to turn a computer’s creation into a thrilling, high-stakes drama.
In 2016, Toby Huss won the Critics’ Choice Television Award for Best Supporting Actor for his performance as John Bosworth. The show’s exploration of ambition, failure, and friendship resonated deeply with its audience, making it a cult favorite.
The Leftovers
Award: Critics’ Choice Television Award for Most Exciting New Series (2014)
When 2% of the world’s population mysteriously vanishes, the town of Mapleton is left grappling with the unexplained loss. The Leftovers dives into the psychological and emotional aftermath experienced by those left behind. The show’s haunting atmosphere and philosophical undertones make it a profound watch.
Winning the Critics’ Choice Television Award for Most Exciting New Series in 2014, the show has been lauded for its ambitious storytelling and stellar performances. Varietyhailed it as a “masterpiece of existential angst.”
Counterpart
Award: Saturn Award for Best New Media TV Series (2019)
Counterpart is a mind-bending thriller centered around a low-level UN employee who discovers that his organization is hiding a gateway to a parallel universe. The duality theme is brilliantly executed, with J.K. Simmons delivering a tour-de-force performance in two contrasting roles.
Owing to its intricate plot and compelling character arcs. The Hollywood Reporter praised it for being “sci-fi at its most cerebral and gripping.”
Patriot
Award: Gracie Award for Best Actress in a Comedy Series (2018)
Patriot blends dark comedy with espionage to tell the story of an intelligence officer tasked with preventing Iran from going nuclear. The show’s unique blend of humor, drama, and suspense sets it apart in the spy genre.
It won the Gracie Award for Best Actress in a Comedy Series, thanks to the stellar performance by Kathleen Munroe. The New York Times called it “a rare gem that keeps you laughing even as the tension rises.”
Better Things
Award: Peabody Award (2016)
Better Things offers a raw and realistic portrayal of single motherhood through the eyes of Sam Fox, an actress raising three daughters. The show excels in its honest depiction of everyday struggles and the complexities of familial relationships.
Winning the Peabody Award, Better Things has been commended for its authenticity and emotional resonance. Rolling Stone lauded it as “a heartfelt and unfiltered look at modern motherhood.”
Banshee
Award: Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Special Visual Effects in a Supporting Role (2013)
Banshee is a high-octane action series centered around an ex-con who assumes the identity of a murdered sheriff in a small town. The program keeps viewers on the edge of their seats with a combination of complex plotlines and exciting action scenes.
it was recognized for its outstanding production quality with a Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Special Visual Effects in a Supporting Role. IGN described it as “an adrenaline-pumping thrill ride.”
Terriers
Award: Television Critics Association Award for Outstanding Achievement in Drama (2011)
Recognized with the Television Critics Association Award for Outstanding Achievement in Drama, it has been praised for its engaging and original storytelling. Slatecalled it “one of the best shows you’ve probably never seen.”
Terriers follow two unlicensed private investigators who are solving crimes in Ocean Beach. The show stands out for its witty dialogue, complex characters, and a perfect blend of comedy and drama.
The Expanse
Award: Hugo Award for Best Dramatic Presentation (Short Form) (2017)
Set in a future where humanity has colonized the solar system, The Expanse explores political intrigue, social struggles, and the mysteries of space. The show’s rich world-building and multi-layered narrative make it a standout in the sci-fi genre.
Winning the Hugo Award for Best Dramatic Presentation in 2017, it has been praised for its complex storytelling and stunning visuals. The Big Think hailed it as “the best sci-fi show since Battlestar Galactica.”
Killing Eve
Award: Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series (2018)
Killing Eve is an addictive thriller that follows the cat-and-mouse game between MI6 agent Eve Polastri and psychopathic assassin Villanelle. The show’s sharp writing, dark humor, and dynamic leads have made it a critical and commercial success.
Star Jodie Comer won the Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series, cementing her status as one of TV’s most compelling actresses. The Guardian called the show “a sly, stylish drama that never skips a beat.”
Person of Interest
Award: People’s Choice Award for Favorite New TV Drama (2012)
Person of Interest explores the idea of a machine that can predict crimes before they happen. Combining elements of sci-fi, crime drama, and philosophical inquiry, the show captivates viewers with its thought-provoking plot and dynamic characters.
The series won the People’s Choice Award for Favorite New TV Drama in 2012, thanks to its innovative premise and compelling storytelling. Wired lauded it as “a heady mix of action, intrigue, and ethical quandaries.”
Penny Dreadful
Award: Satellite Award for Best Television Series – Genre (2014)
Penny Dreadful masterfully weaves together classic horror literature characters into a dark and atmospheric narrative. The show’s gothic aesthetic and deep character explorations make it a must-watch for horror enthusiasts.
The show has been praised for its visual style and storytelling ambition. The Guardian described it as “a beautifully crafted horror series with a soul.”
15 Obscure Movies That Definitely Existed (We Promise)
Not every great movie can be viewed everywhere, all the time, and all at once, even in the age of multiverses. The opposite is true: many excellent films have vanished from popular culture. This is mostly because, as the recently departed Jean-Luc Godard eloquently observed, “old films” are frequently seen differently than older art pieces.
15 Obscure Movies That Definitely Existed (We Promise)
15 Movies With Bizarrely Similar (And Specific) Plots That Came Out At The Same Time
Whether a coincidence, a popular trend, or something more dubious, it provides a fascinating study. Explore 15 pairs of movies with strangely similar plots, premiering within months of each other. Get ready for an uncanny cinematic journey!
15 Movies With Bizarrely Similar (And Specific) Plots That Came Out At The Same Time
15 Movies That Hit All the Right Notes with Their Music
Music can transform a movie from a visual experience to an emotional rollercoaster. The right soundtrack doesn’t just accompany the visuals; it amplifies the story, characters, and emotions, making every scene unforgettable.
15 MoviesThat Hit All the Right Notes with Their Music
17 Unforgettable Movies You’ll Want to Watch Again and Again
Let’s admit it, we’ve all got that movie. The one we could recite line for line, scene for scene, yet still find ourselves reaching for the DVD or streaming it online on a lazy Sunday afternoon.
17 Unforgettable Movies You’ll Want to Watch Again and Again
