17 Once-Beloved Foods That Americans Have Left Behind
This post may contain affiliate links.
Have you tasted a dish as a kid that you can’t stop remembering but can’t seem to find anymore? Some foods long beloved in America have been left behind in the changing times.
The Barbecue Lab says consumers’ tastes have shifted, with 93% of Americans wanting to eat healthy. We continue to pine for our past favorites, but most of us no longer eat those mouthwatering bites in favor of foods that align with today’s healthy living options.
Jell-O Salads
In the middle part of the 20th century, Jell-O salads were a staple menu at potlucks and family gatherings. These colorful, gelatin-based dishes often included fruits, vegetables, and sometimes also meat, giving a sweet and savory combination that baffled (or pleased some).
At family dinners, their tangy taste and wobbly texture were sources of both delight and humor. Jell-O salads may have been all the rage at one time, but their sugar content has rendered them out of style, along with more sophisticated salad options. Today, they are most remembered as a quirky relic of culinary history.
Meatloaf
Once, meatloaf was the epitome of home-cooked comfort food: baked to perfection ground beef mixed with breadcrumbs and spices and often topped with a tangy ketchup glaze. During the mid-1900s, its simplicity and affordability made it a family favorite.
Yet, cooking changed over time as culinary tastes evolved and eating healthier became the thing — meatloaf lost its appeal. While meatloaf is on its way down, it still fills many hearts with the memories of family dinners centered around this dish.
Aspic
Yet another gelatin based dish that has somehow slipped into obscurity is aspic. A clear and savory jelly encasing meats, vegetable and seafood. In the early 20th century, the shimmering presentation was a status symbol, appearing on the tables of formal gatherings.
Unfortunately, the preparation was so time-consuming and the texture so unusual that it led to its decline in popularity. Aspic today is a culinary curiosity that pops up now and then at retro-theme dinner parties.
Ambrosia Salad
Ambrosia salad, often referred to as “food of the gods,” was a popular dessert salad in the American South. It was made with whipped cream, marshmallows, coconut, and canned fruit, offering a sweet and fluffy treat.
It became a hit at picnics and for holiday meals for its blend of textures and tropical flavors. Ambrosia salad, however, has been on its way to the annals of culinary history for some time: over time, ambrosia has been supplanted by more health-conscious desserts, and the consumption of canned fruit has tapered off.
Deviled Ham
Many American households during the 1950s to ’60s kept deviled ham in the pantry. Used in sandwiches and hors d’oeuvres, this canned meat spread was about as fancy as a spread could get, seasoned with spices and vinegar.
It was convenient and did not go bad fast, so it was an easy choice for busy families. However, as fresh and artisanal food options became more available, deviled ham lost a toehold in the American diet. Today, those who remember the special taste of deviled ham realize it is a nostalgic memory.
Baked Alaska
Once upon a time, Baked Alaska was king of the dessert menus of fancy restaurants and dinner parties. Ice cream, cake, and toasted meringue came together in one layer in this show-stopper of a dish.
Flambé presentations in the dramatic presentation delighted audiences and the taste buds. But with its labor-intensive preparation and the rise of simpler, more modern desserts, Baked Alaska has largely flown off the contemporary menu.
Salisbury Steak
A cousin to meatloaf, Salisbury steak was an early mid 20th century popular comfort food. It was an American family food made from ground beef formed into patties and served with gravy.
Dr. James Salisbury is credited with inventing the dish, and promoted it as a health food in the late 1800s. But as preferences in dining began to branch off towards more creative tastes and more healthful choices, Salisbury steak fell by the wayside.
Waldorf Salad
In the early 1900s the Waldorf salad, an advanced dish at the Waldorf Astoria Hotel in New York, was created. It was composed of apples, celery, walnuts and mayonnaise and it was the perfect combination of flavors and textures.
An elegant simplicity made this salad popular at the top of the dining scale and social events. The popularity of the salad started to dwindle as new, more exotic salads became popular with diners. For those who remember it, it is still one of those nostalgic dishes.
Liver and Onions
Liver and onions was a fairly common American home dish during the Great Depression and World War II. Liver is cheap and full of nutrition, a good choice for those on a budget. Fried onions normally balanced the liver’s strong taste.
But as tastes got more sophisticated and there were more protein options, liver, and onions kind of fell out of favor. Today, it is seen as an acquired taste, and it is remembered by those who ate it as children.
Chicken a la King
In American cuisine from the early to mid-20th century, chicken a la King was a luxurious dish. It featured chanced chicken, mushrooms, and peppers in a creamy sauce served over toast or rice for a meal.
This was a culinary tradition of American elegance, popular at fancy hotels and dinner parties. When global cuisine became a thing, Chicken a la King’s time had passed, and it became a little nostalgic for people who tasted it in its heyday.
Tapioca Pudding
In American households during the mid-1900s, tapioca pudding was a much-loved dessert. It came in the form of tapioca pearls, sugar, milk and eggs and was as simple and as satisfying a treat.
The delicious vanilla combination and the pudding’s unique texture was loved by children as much as adults did. But then as instant pudding mixes and other creative dessert ideas came out, tapioca pudding lost its luster. For those who have been lucky enough to have tasted it, it’s still a nostalgic treat.
Liverwurst
Once a common item in American kitchens, liverwurst is a spreadable sausage made from liver and other organ meats. It was rich and savory and appealed to many who often enjoyed it on sandwiches or as a snack with crackers.
The affordability and convenience of liverwurst made it a staple during the mid-20th century. But it fell from favor as deli meats grew and diets changed. It’s nostalgic today and reminiscence—in its heyday, it was a special treat.
Tomato Aspic
A mid Century side dish was tomato aspic, a gelatin-based dish. It consisted of tomato juice, gelatin, and seasoning of different sorts and provided a savory, not to mention refreshing, accompaniment to meals.
It was a favorite at dinner parties in part because of its vibrant color and unique presentation. But then, when fresh vegetable salads came into vogue, tomato aspic became passé.
Chipped Beef on Toast
Chipped beef on toast, also known as “SOS” (short for “s**t on a shingle”), was a popular dish in military mess halls and American homes during the mid-20th century. It was a meal of thin slices of dried beef in a creamy white sauce, served over toast, and it was quick and filling.
The dish was simple enough and cheap enough to be a staple for many families. But as dining tastes changed, chipped beef on toast fell in disuse, and only memories remained for those who enjoyed it.
Tomato Soup Cake
During The Great Depression, tomato soup cake was a creative dessert. It is a moist, flavorful treat consisting of canned tomato soup, flour, sugar, and spices. Its unique ingredient mix piqued the interest of bakers, and its frugal dessert option in hard economic times won fans.
However, as more traditional cake recipes came into view, tomato soup cake fell out of style. There is still something quirky about it as a reminder of American culinary genius.
Corned Beef Hash
Corned beef hash was made from corned beef, potatoes and onions, fried until crispy. American diners and homes loved it as an appetizing and filling means of starting one’s day. Because it was an affordable, versatile meal, many families chose to make it a go to meal.
However, as people started preferring light and no oil breakfasts, corned beef hash was no more in demand. Those who recall its comforting taste consider it a nostalgic dish.
Floating Island
In the early to mid-20th century, floating island was a dessert that would dazzle guests at dinner parties. It was made with poached meringue islands floating in a sea of custard and was light and airy. Its delicate flavors, along with a visual appeal, have been a favorite of hosts wanting to impress their guests.
But as simpler and more modern desserts became popular, floating island became a disappearing entity on menus. Those who appreciate its refined charm will still remember it as a nostalgia.
Disclaimer – This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information.
20 Quintessentially American Foods That Will Make Foreigners Gag and Cringe!
20 Quintessentially American Foods That Will Make Foreigners Gag and Cringe!