17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most

This post may contain affiliate links.

In many countries, tipping is more than just a way to show appreciation for good service; it’s an integral part of the dining experience. However, certain tipping habits can frustrate and even offend restaurant servers.

From stinginess to overcomplication, here’s a look at the 17 most common tipping faux pas that get under servers’ skin, peppered with absolute statements from those on the front line.

The Verbal Tipper

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by: ANTONI SHKRABA production

“Compliments don’t pay the bills,” states Alisha from San Francisco. A verbal tip, where patrons shower servers with praise but skimp on the tip, is both disheartening and financially painful. While kind words are appreciated, they can’t substitute for a fair tip.

The Conditional Tipper

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by: Antoni Shkraba

“I’ll give you a good tip if you…” This approach, where the tip is used as leverage for extra favours or freebies, puts servers in an uncomfortable position. It turns a gesture of appreciation into a transactional maneuver.

The Non-Tippers for Small Orders

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by: RDNE Stock project

A small order doesn’t necessarily mean a small effort for the server, but the tipping often doesn’t reflect this. A coffee refill requires the same steps as delivering a three-course meal, a fact lost on those who tip minimally for smaller tabs.

The Under-Tipper

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by:Karolina Grabowska

“I’ll never understand how someone can justify tipping less than 15% for good service,” shares Emily, a Chicago server. A SpotOn survey reveals that most tipped workers anticipate a standard tip of 15% to 20%. 

Customers must recognize that tips form a substantial part of a server’s earnings in the service sector. Inadequate tipping can significantly affect their livelihood.

The Overly Complicated Tipper

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by:Karolina Grabowska

Complex mathematical equations don’t belong at the dinner table. “Some customers try to make a science out of tipping. Just round up and call it a day,” shares Mark from a New York restaurant.

Servers appreciate straightforwardness, not when customers turn payment into a calculus exam.

The Negotiator

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by: ANTONI SHKRABA production

Some patrons believe tipping is a negotiation, offering less for minor complaints. This habit undermines the server’s effort and is seen as an excuse to tip poorly.

The Coin Giver

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by: Gina Sanders

Many servers have experienced the dreaded “coin giver” – a customer who leaves only coins as a tip. While any tip is appreciated, leaving just coins can be seen as disrespectful and cheap.

The Appraiser

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by: RDNE Stock project

Some patrons tip based on assessing the server’s lifestyle or perceived need. “I hate when customers assume I don’t need a good tip because I’m young,” reveals Jessica, a college student and part-time server. This judgmental approach is both unfair and frustrating.

The Flashy Tipper

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by:Karolina Grabowska

Tipping extravagantly to impress a date or a group is a double-edged sword. While the gesture is generous, it can create unrealistic expectations for future tips, especially when the same patrons return for regular service.

The Social Media Promiser

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by: Tim Douglas

“I’ll give you a shoutout on my Instagram instead of a tip.” This modern-day dilemma has servers groaning nationwide. Social media exposure doesn’t equate to financial compensation; such offers are more insulting than beneficial.

The Late-Night Stiff

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Images provided by Cottonbro Studio

Servers working the late shift often face patrons who either forget to tip or decide it’s unnecessary after a night of drinking. These servers rely on tips to make a living, and a zero tip can mean the difference between paying bills or falling behind.

The Table Hogger

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by: RDNE Stock project

Occupying a table for hours but tipping as if you’ve only been there for a short meal is a big no-no. This situation is incredibly frustrating when the server has limited tables and needs to turn them over quickly to make enough money.

The Split Bill Minimizer

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image [provided by:RDNE Stock project

When groups request separate checks and each person tips on their small portion, the overall tip often falls. “It’s disheartening when a large party does this,” says Carlos, noting the extra work involved with split bills.

The Event Evangelist

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by: RDNE Stock project

Leaving promotional material or religious pamphlets instead of a tip is inappropriate and highly annoying to servers. 

The Holiday Scrooge

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by:Pressmaster

A common pet peeve is not recognizing the extra effort that goes into working holidays and special occasions with an appropriate tip. Statistics show that tipping generously during the holidays is appreciated, with many servers wishing for a little extra cheer in the form of a better tip.

The Advice Giver

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by: Ksenia Chernaya

Instead of a tip, leaving unsolicited advice or comments on how to improve service isn’t helpful. “A note saying ‘Smile more!’ doesn’t pay the rent,” a cafĂ© worker says.

The Passive Aggressive Tipper

17 Common Tipping Habits That Annoy Restaurant Servers The Most
Image provided by Cottonbro Studio

Leaving a small tip to make a statement about something minor during the meal is passive-aggressive and unhelpful. Feedback is appreciated, but docking the tip isn’t how to provide it.

Tipping remains a crucial element of the dining experience, directly impacting those who work hard to make our meals enjoyable. While most patrons aim to show appreciation through their tips, avoiding these common tipping faux pas can ensure that the gesture is received as intended— as a sincere thank you for exceptional service.

Teaching Dining Etiquette to Americans: Here Are the 20 Most Common Mistakes We’ve Seen

Teaching Dining Etiquette to Americans: Here Are the 20 Most Common Mistakes We

In our experience teaching dining etiquette, we’ve encountered a wide range of American dining habits – from those who prefer steak without forks to others who use salad utensils like drumsticks.

Teaching Dining Etiquette to Americans: Here Are the 20 Most Common Mistakes We’ve Seen

22 Red Flags That Scream ‘Run’ When Dining At A Restaurant

20 Red Flags That Scream 'Run' When Dining At A Restaurant

A bad dining experience can be the worst. Poor service, dirty tables, cold food, and unhygienic practices are red flags to watch out for when dining out. To ensure a good restaurant visit, we’ve compiled twenty warning signs to make you run for the door.

22 Red Flags That Scream ‘Run’ When Dining At A Restaurant

DIY Faux Branch (With a Twist!)

Faux branches are fantastic, but they can sometimes look fake. And the good ones are expensive!

DIY Faux Branch (With a Twist!)

Similar Posts