14 Vintage Toys That Are Now Valuable Collectibles

This post may contain affiliate links.

Toys — whether it’s that squeaky sounding rubber duck, or the comforting weight of the action figure to which you’ve clung for so many years — have this magical ability to remind us of the simpler times. But here’s the kicker: some of those long forgotten toys gathering dust in attics or basements could now be worth a small fortune. Those playthings you dragged through mud or had your dog chew on might just pay for a luxury vacation.

Vintage toys carry more than nostalgia, they’re a window into history. Trends, culture and craftsmanship of their time are reflected in them. Collectors are hard on the hunt for these relics. We’ll take a trip down memory lane and retrace some of the most beloved toys that are now making a big splash in the collectibles world.

Hot Wheels Redlines

Photo Credit: South Sea Surfer/Wikimedia Commons

For decades, Hot Wheels cars have sped across carpets and sidewalks, but if you’ve got a “Redline” from the late 1960s or early 1970s, you’ve got a goldmine. The early models, named for the red stripe on their tires, can sell for hundreds, or even thousands of dollars, particularly rare designs such as the “Beach Bomb” or “Custom Camaro.”

PEZ Dispensers

You know, those little candy dispensers with character heads? Yep, they’re collectible. Not surprisingly, PEZ dispensers, even of the limited edition or discontinued characters, can be surprisingly valuable. For example, the “Astronaut B” dispenser sold for more than $32,000. Who knew candy storage was so lucrative?

Star Wars Action Figures

Photo Credit: Grzegorz Czapski/Shutterstock

When “Star Wars” debuted in 1977, it wasn’t just a cultural phenomena, it was a merchandising juggernaut. Factory sealed early action figures are extremely valuable. In an auction, a 1978 Luke Skywalker figure with a ‘double telescoping’ lightsaber sold for $25,000. May the force, and fortune, be with you.

Fisher-Price Little People

Photo Credit: Daniel Waters/Shutterstock

These chunky, colorful figures were staple in many households from the 1960s onward. Rare sets, like the 1960s wooden Little People, can command hundreds of dollars, but on the face of it, these wooden little people toys sound simple. If you have the Play Family School set, you are looking at a tidy sum!

G.I. Joe Action Figures

First ever action figure G.I. Joe was introduced in 1964. Collectors love vintage models, especially if their original packaging is intact. A G.I. Joe Navy Seal figure, one of the rare prototypes, sold for more than $200,000 at auction in 2003. This is talk about earning your stripes!

The Nintendo Entertainment System (NES)

Vintage Electronics in Your Attic Worth a Fortune Today — Image Credit: Evan-Amos/Wikimedia Commons

Not only did the NES redefine gaming, it also caused a collector’s frenzy. If you have an original console in good shape, you could make a couple hundred dollars. While complete, factory sealed NES games like “Super Mario Bros.” and “The Legend of Zelda” can go for tens of thousands.

Cabbage Patch Kids

In the 1980s, these chubby faced dolls created a shopping craze, and some of them are still worth a pretty penny. Those original hand stitched dolls, called Little People, can fetch thousands of dollars. Mass market Cabbage Patch Kids in perfect condition are worth something.

Polly Pocket

"22 Iconic 90s Must-Haves That Are Now Gone Forever" — Image Credit: EvelynGiggles/Wikimedia Commons

Tiny Playsets with Dolls in them? Genius! Remember Polly Pockets from the late ’80s and early ’90s? Now, first generation sets, especially with the original accessories and cases, are hot commodities. Rare sets can go as high as $500.

Beanie Babies

Not all Beanie Babies have held their value, but some rare ones still do. Limited edition or the “Princess Diana” bear can sell for thousands. Remember, as long as you’ve got the original tags, you are good to make bank—no tag, no jackpot.

Barbie Dolls of the Early Days

While Barbie made her first debut in 1959, the first edition dolls are extremely popular now. These original Barbies are worth thousands, with their iconic black and white striped swimsuit, and signature ponytail. According to Business Insider, a mint-condition Barbie No. 1 sold for $27,450, in fact. Quite impressive for a $3 doll.

Transformers Toys

Photo Credit: Aisyaqihimaranas/Shutterstock

Early Transformers toys from the 1980s have always been cool “robots in disguise,” but are now collector gold. You can actually get yourself Optimus Prime or Megatron mint condition with original packaging for over a couple thousand.

Teddy Ruxpin

It was ahead of its time: The 1980s talking bear that read stories to kids. Now, original Teddy Ruxpin dolls in working condition, complete with tapes and outfits, are a novelty for collectors. They will sell for hundreds depending on its condition.

He-Man and the Masters of the Universe

The 1980s were filled with He-Man figures as well as their colorful cast of heroes and villains. Figure like ‘Laser Power He-Man’ or ‘Eternia Playset’ are rare, and will set you back thousands of dollars, that’s how much power Grayskull still has!

Lite-Brite

Lite-Brite sets from the 1970s and 1980s are simple but mesmerizing – and they’ve become collectibles. Original templates and pegs in a complete set can fetch a few hundred dollars. You wouldn’t think that something so simple would light up a collector’s wallet, but it does.

Disclaimer: This list is solely the author’s opinion based on research and publicly available information.